Why Is It Bad To Use A Nipple Shield While Breastfeeding?

Let’s delve into the realm of breastfeeding and explore why using a nipple shield may not always be the best choice for nursing moms. Before we unravel the potential risks associated with nipple shields, it’s essential to understand what they are and why some moms opt for their usage.

Definition of a Nipple Shield

A nipple shield is a thin, flexible silicone cover that is placed over the nipple and areola during breastfeeding. It is primarily designed to assist babies with latching onto the breast, especially in cases where there are latching difficulties, flat or inverted nipples, or nipple pain.

Purpose of Using a Nipple Shield While Breastfeeding

The primary goal of using a nipple shield is to aid in facilitating a proper latch for the baby, thereby ensuring effective milk transfer and reducing discomfort during nursing sessions. While they can be beneficial in specific situations, it’s crucial to weigh the advantages against the potential drawbacks.

Understanding Nipple Shields

Material and Design of Nipple Shields

Nipple shields are commonly made from soft, thin silicone that mimics the feel of human skin. They are typically shaped like a thin, round disc with a nipple protrusion that fits over the mother’s nipple.

How Nipple Shields Work During Breastfeeding

When placed over the nipple, nipple shields act as a barrier between the baby’s mouth and the breast. They can make it easier for babies to latch onto the breast by providing a more pronounced target for them to grasp onto during feeding.

Correct and Incorrect Usage of Nipple Shields

While nipple shields can be a helpful tool in certain scenarios, using them incorrectly or as a sole solution for breastfeeding challenges can lead to potential issues that may affect both the mother and the baby.

Potential Risks of Using Nipple Shields

Impact on Milk Supply

One significant risk of using a nipple shield is the potential decrease in milk supply. Since the nipple is not directly stimulated by the baby’s suckling, it may signal the body to produce less milk, leading to supply issues over time.

Effect on Baby’s Latch and Sucking Pattern

Another concern is the impact on the baby’s latch and sucking pattern. Using a shield can alter the way a baby latches onto the breast, possibly affecting their feeding efficiency and causing nipple confusion, which may complicate breastfeeding.

Hygiene Concerns Associated with Nipple Shields

Keeping nipple shields clean and sanitized is crucial to prevent infections or mastitis. If not cleaned properly, nipple shields can harbor bacteria that may transfer to the baby’s mouth during feeding, posing a risk to both the baby and the mother.

Nipple Soreness and Complications

Continued use of a nipple shield can lead to nipple soreness or trauma due to the increased pressure applied during feeding. This can result in cracked nipples, discomfort, and potential complications that may hinder the breastfeeding experience.

Dependency on Nipple Shields

One of the most significant risks of using a nipple shield is the potential dependency it can create. Babies may become accustomed to feeding with the shield, making it challenging to wean them off and transition to direct breastfeeding, which is vital for long-term breastfeeding success.

Tips for Safely Using Nipple Shields

Seeking Professional Advice Before Use

Before incorporating a nipple shield into your breastfeeding routine, consulting with a lactation consultant or healthcare provider can help assess whether it is necessary and provide guidance on proper usage.

Ensuring Proper Fit and Size

Choosing the correct size and fit for a nipple shield is essential to ensure optimal performance and comfort during breastfeeding sessions. A well-fitted shield can help prevent issues such as nipple pain and improper latch.

How to Wean Off Nipple Shields

Gradually weaning your baby off the nipple shield can help facilitate a smooth transition to direct breastfeeding. Offering the breast without the shield during shorter feeding sessions and seeking support during the process can aid in successful weaning.

Why Is It Bad To Use A Nipple Shield While Breastfeeding?

Conclusion

In conclusion, while nipple shields can be a valuable tool in certain breastfeeding situations, it is essential to be aware of the potential risks they pose. From impacting milk supply and latch effectiveness to hygiene concerns and dependency issues, understanding the drawbacks of nipple shields can help mothers make informed decisions about their usage. By seeking professional guidance, ensuring proper fit, and aiming to gradually wean off the shield when appropriate, mothers can navigate the challenges associated with nipple shields and optimize their breastfeeding journey.

Photo of author

Nancy Sherman

Nancy Sherman has more than a decade of experience in education and is passionate about helping schools, teachers, and students succeed. She began her career as a Teaching Fellow in NY where she worked with educators to develop their instructional practice. Since then she held diverse roles in the field including Educational Researcher, Academic Director for a non-profit foundation, Curriculum Expert and Coach, while also serving on boards of directors for multiple organizations. She is trained in Project-Based Learning, Capstone Design (PBL), Competency-Based Evaluation (CBE) and Social Emotional Learning Development (SELD).