Picky Eater’s Grocery List: Essential Foods for Parents

Picky eating is a common challenge faced by many parents and individuals. It can be frustrating to deal with, especially when trying to provide a well-balanced and nutritious diet. In this article, we will explore a detailed list of foods that picky eaters tend to dislike or avoid.

One category of foods that picky eaters often steer clear of is odorous vegetables. Vegetables like broccoli, Brussels sprouts, and cauliflower can have a strong smell that some individuals find off-putting. The distinct aroma of these veggies can make them unappealing to picky eaters.

Seafood and sushi are also commonly disliked by picky eaters. The strong smell and taste of seafood can be overwhelming for some individuals, leading them to avoid it altogether. Similarly, the texture and flavor of sushi, especially raw fish, may not appeal to picky eaters.

Condiments, such as mayonnaise, mustard, and ketchup, can be a challenge for picky eaters as well. These sauces often have strong flavors that may overpower the taste of the food they are paired with. Picky eaters may prefer to have their food plain or without any additional condiments.

Spicy foods can also be a big turn-off for picky eaters. The heat and intensity of spices can be too much for their taste buds to handle. Picky eaters may prefer milder flavors and avoid foods that are known for their spiciness.

Surprisingly, even sandwiches can be a source of dislike for picky eaters. The combination of different ingredients and textures in a sandwich can be overwhelming for some individuals. Picky eaters may prefer to have their food items separate rather than combined in a sandwich.

Now that we have explored the foods that picky eaters tend to avoid, let’s discuss some meal ideas that can be enjoyed by picky eaters. These meals are designed to be customizable and allow picky eaters to assemble their own dinner creations:

1. Baked Potato Bar: Provide a variety of toppings like cheese, sour cream, bacon bits, and chopped vegetables, allowing picky eaters to choose their favorite toppings for their baked potato.

2. Pizza Bagels: Toasted bagels topped with tomato sauce, cheese, and various toppings like pepperoni, mushrooms, and bell peppers. Picky eaters can customize their pizza bagels to their liking.

3. Mac & Cheese with Cauliflower: Sneak in some vegetables by adding steamed cauliflower to a classic macaroni and cheese dish. The cheesy flavor can help mask the taste of the cauliflower.

4. Chicken Fajitas: Serve grilled chicken, sliced bell peppers, onions, and tortillas separately, allowing picky eaters to build their own fajitas.

5. White Bean Burgers: Make homemade bean burgers using white beans, breadcrumbs, and seasonings. Picky eaters can add their preferred toppings like lettuce, tomato, and cheese.

6. Peas & Cheese Tortellini: Cook cheese tortellini and mix in some peas for added nutrition. The cheesy flavor can help entice picky eaters to give it a try.

7. Veggie Wraps: Offer a variety of vegetables, spreads, and tortillas, allowing picky eaters to create their own customized veggie wraps.

8. Chicken Bites, Mashed Yams & Green Beans: Serve bite-sized chicken pieces alongside mashed yams and steamed green beans. This meal provides a variety of flavors and textures for picky eaters to enjoy.

Remember, picky eating can be influenced by various factors including a child’s palate, sensory processing, and personal preferences. It is important to be patient and understanding when dealing with picky eaters. By offering a variety of options and allowing them to have some control over their meals, you can encourage them to try new foods and expand their palate over time.

Picky eaters often have specific dislikes when it comes to certain foods. Odorous vegetables, seafood, condiments, spicy foods, and sandwiches are some of the common foods that picky eaters tend to avoid. However, by providing customizable meal options and incorporating familiar flavors, it is possible to create meals that picky eaters can enjoy.

Picky Eater's Grocery List: Essential Foods for Parents

What Are Common Picky Eater Foods?

Common picky eater foods include odorous vegetables, such as broccoli, Brussels sprouts, and cabbage. These vegetables often have a strong smell that can be off-putting to picky eaters. Additionally, seafood and sushi are often disliked by picky eaters due to their unique textures and flavors. Condiments, such as ketchup, mustard, and mayonnaise, can also be a turn-off for picky eaters who prefer plain flavors. Spicy foods are another common dislike for picky eaters, as the heat can be overwhelming for sensitive taste buds. Lastly, picky eaters may avoid sandwiches, as they often contain a variety of ingredients and flavors that may not be appealing to them.

What Foods Do Picky Kids Eat?

Picky eaters can be quite challenging when it comes to mealtime. However, there are several foods that picky kids tend to enjoy. Here are some examples:

1. Chicken nuggets: Picky eaters often enjoy chicken nuggets due to their familiar taste and texture. Opt for baked or grilled versions for a healthier option.

2. Pasta: Whether it’s spaghetti with marinara sauce or macaroni and cheese, pasta is a popular choice among picky eaters. You can even sneak in some veggies by using vegetable-based pasta or adding pureed vegetables to the sauce.

3. PB&J sandwiches: The classic combination of peanut butter and jelly is a staple for many picky eaters. Just make sure to choose a high-quality peanut butter and a jelly or jam without added sugars.

4. Cheese quesadillas: Quesadillas are simple and customizable, making them a great option for picky eaters. You can add some protein by including grilled chicken or beans.

5. Pancakes or waffles: Breakfast foods like pancakes or waffles can be a hit with picky eaters. You can make them healthier by using whole wheat flour or adding fruit purees to the batter.

6. Yogurt: Many picky eaters enjoy the smooth and creamy texture of yogurt. Look for options with less added sugar and consider adding fresh fruits or granola for added nutrition.

7. Smoothies: Smoothies can be a sneaky way to incorporate fruits and vegetables into a picky eater’s diet. Experiment with different combinations and flavors to find what your child enjoys.

8. Grilled cheese sandwiches: Grilled cheese sandwiches are a classic comfort food that many picky eaters adore. Use whole wheat bread and add some thinly sliced vegetables for added nutrition.

9. Fruit: While picky eaters may not enjoy all types of fruits, there are usually a few options they will eat. Offer a variety of fruits and let them choose their favorites.

10. Snack plates: Sometimes, picky eaters prefer to graze throughout the day rather than sit down for a traditional meal. Create snack plates with a variety of finger foods like cheese cubes, sliced veggies, crackers, and hummus.

Remember, every child is different, so what works for one picky eater may not work for another. It’s essential to keep offering a variety of foods and involve your child in meal planning and preparation to encourage them to try new things.

What Are the 5 P’s Of Picky Eating?

The 5 P’s of picky eating are palette, pain, processing, pressure, and power.

1. Palette: This refers to how a child chews and processes food in their mouth. Some children may have difficulties with texture, taste, or even temperature, which can make them picky eaters.

2. Pain: Some children may experience pain or discomfort while eating due to underlying medical conditions such as oral sensory issues or gastrointestinal problems. This can lead to selective eating patterns and a limited food repertoire.

3. Processing: Children with sensory processing issues may struggle with the sensory aspects of eating, such as the smell, taste, or texture of certain foods. This can result in a limited range of accepted foods and a preference for familiar or “safe” options.

4. Pressure: External pressure from parents, caregivers, or peers can contribute to picky eating habits. Forcing or pressuring a child to eat certain foods can create negative associations with those foods and reinforce picky eating behaviors.

5. Power: Picky eating can also be a way for children to assert their independence and control over their environment. By refusing certain foods, they may feel a sense of power and autonomy. This can make it challenging for parents to address picky eating without creating power struggles.

The 5 P’s of picky eating are palette, pain, processing, pressure, and power. Understanding these factors can help parents and caregivers better address and support children with selective eating habits.

What Will Picky Eaters Not Eat?

Picky eaters, individuals who have strong preferences and dislikes when it comes to food, tend to avoid a variety of foods. Here is a detailed list of 40 foods that picky eaters commonly dislike and avoid:

1. Avocados: Picky eaters often dislike the texture and taste of avocados.
2. Beef/Ground beef: Some picky eaters have an aversion to the texture or taste of beef.
3. Black Licorice: The strong flavor of black licorice is often off-putting for picky eaters.
4. Blueberries: The texture and taste of blueberries may not appeal to picky eaters.
5. Broccoli: Picky eaters often dislike the taste and texture of broccoli.
6. Brussels sprouts: The bitter taste and texture of Brussels sprouts are often disliked by picky eaters.
7. Cauliflower: Picky eaters may dislike the taste or texture of cauliflower.
8. Celery: The fibrous texture and mild flavor of celery can be unappealing to picky eaters.
9. Cilantro: The strong, distinctive taste of cilantro is often disliked by picky eaters.
10. Coconut: Picky eaters may dislike the taste or texture of coconut.
11. Coffee: The bitter taste of coffee may not appeal to picky eaters.
12. Cottage cheese: The texture and taste of cottage cheese are often disliked by picky eaters.
13. Cucumbers: Picky eaters may dislike the texture or taste of cucumbers.
14. Eggplant: The texture and taste of eggplant can be unappealing to picky eaters.
15. Fish: Some picky eaters dislike the taste or smell of fish.
16. Grapefruit: Picky eaters may find the taste of grapefruit too bitter or sour.
17. Green beans: The texture and taste of green beans may not appeal to picky eaters.
18. Kale: Picky eaters may dislike the bitter taste and tough texture of kale.
19. Kiwi: The texture and taste of kiwi may not be enjoyed by picky eaters.
20. Lamb: Some picky eaters dislike the taste or smell of lamb.
21. Lentils: The texture and taste of lentils can be unappealing to picky eaters.
22. Mushrooms: Picky eaters often dislike the texture or earthy taste of mushrooms.
23. Mustard: The strong flavor of mustard may not be liked by picky eaters.
24. Olives: Picky eaters may dislike the briny taste and texture of olives.
25. Onions: The strong flavor and pungent smell of onions can be off-putting to picky eaters.
26. Peppers (bell, jalapeno, etc.): The spiciness or strong flavor of peppers may not be enjoyed by picky eaters.
27. Pineapple: Picky eaters may dislike the texture or taste of pineapple.
28. Pork: Some picky eaters have an aversion to the taste or texture of pork.
29. Quinoa: The texture and taste of quinoa may not appeal to picky eaters.
30. Radishes: Picky eaters often dislike the strong, peppery taste of radishes.
31. Salmon: The taste or smell of salmon may not be liked by picky eaters.
32. Sardines: Picky eaters may dislike the taste or smell of sardines.
33. Spinach: The texture and taste of spinach can be unappealing to picky eaters.
34. Tofu: Some picky eaters dislike the texture or taste of tofu.
35. Tomatoes: Picky eaters may dislike the texture or taste of tomatoes.
36. Tuna: The taste or smell of tuna may not be enjoyed by picky eaters.
37. Turkey: Some picky eaters dislike the taste or texture of turkey.
38. Venison: The taste or smell of venison may not appeal to picky eaters.
39. Watermelon: Picky eaters may find the texture or taste of watermelon unappealing.
40. Zucchini: The texture and taste of zucchini can be disliked by picky eaters.

Keep in mind that individual preferences may vary, and while these foods are commonly disliked by picky eaters, it does not apply to everyone.

Conclusion

Picky eaters have a wide range of foods that they dislike and avoid. Odorous vegetables, seafood, sushi, condiments, and spicy foods are some common examples. Picky eaters also tend to avoid sandwiches, which can limit their options for quick and easy meals. However, there are plenty of delicious and nutritious meal ideas that can cater to picky eaters’ preferences. A baked potato bar allows them to assemble their own dinner creations, while pizza bagels and mac & cheese with cauliflower offer familiar flavors in a new way. Chicken fajitas, white bean burgers, and veggie wraps provide protein and variety, while peas & cheese tortellini and chicken bites with mashed yams and green beans offer balanced and satisfying meals. Understanding the 5 P’s of picky eating, which include palette, pain, processing, pressure, and power, can help parents and caregivers better address the challenges that picky eaters face. By being aware of these factors and providing a supportive and varied food environment, picky eaters can gradually expand their food preferences and develop a healthier relationship with food.

Photo of author

Nancy Sherman

Nancy Sherman has more than a decade of experience in education and is passionate about helping schools, teachers, and students succeed. She began her career as a Teaching Fellow in NY where she worked with educators to develop their instructional practice. Since then she held diverse roles in the field including Educational Researcher, Academic Director for a non-profit foundation, Curriculum Expert and Coach, while also serving on boards of directors for multiple organizations. She is trained in Project-Based Learning, Capstone Design (PBL), Competency-Based Evaluation (CBE) and Social Emotional Learning Development (SELD).